About the Site:

  • A blog about travel, communication, social sciences and mobilities


Ads

Blogroll

The touristic critic of tourism, the other part of the problem

January 3rd, 2007 by Jorge

30 years ago, Dean Maccannell wrote this:

The touristic critic of tourism is not an analysis of tourism: it’s part of the problem (…) The touristic critic of tourism is based on the desire to outpower other “simple” tourists and reach a deeper appreciation of society and culture (…) All tourists want, at some point, this deeper commitment with society and culture; it’s a basic component of the motivation to travel.

Maccannell summarizes in this paragraph the eternal critic of the “traveler” over “tourists”. That is, that the traveler knows how travel better since, apparently, he has a “better understanding of the world”. That they use the same means of transportation and that they use the same payment systems in hotels and hostels are things that are usually overlooked. Against certain common senses, the mobility of the “traveler” around the world does not deserve to be studied differently than the “tourist’s”. Because, for those of us who play analysts, there’s a basic point to be respected: not to assume as obvious the perspective of the interviewed, the one who is part of the object of study. Methodologically, the “traveler’s” justification of “why they are better than tourists” shouldn’t be looked as an analytical form to approach the tourism field. In fact, these descriptions are part of the travel and tourism field, and should be analyzed as any other kind of document or text.

Dean Maccannell’s cite was taken from his book The tourist, originally published in 1976 and translated to spanish by Editorial Melusina in 2003.

Posted in Theories |

2 Responses

  1. Five things you may not know about this Buenos Aires blogger… | Buenos Aires Travel Guide Says:

    […] Now over to some of my favorite fellow Buenos Aires bloggers…I’d like to get to know you all a little better, so I am tagging the following five of you: Diva of Buenos Aires Through My Eyes, Jeff Barry of Buenos Aires, City of Faded Elegance, Jorge Gobbi of Zirma, Ian Mount / Cintra Scott, both of GoodAirs, and Deby Novitz of TangoSpam. If nothing else comes out this, I at least hope some new readers will click on these blogs and discover their delights. Looking forward to you all revealing some juicy secrets! Also, any other bloggers reading this, please feel free to join in on this meme. […]

  2. Rcon Pascua Says:

    If there are people in this world who really know what traveling is, of course these are the travelers themselves and definitely not the tourism critics.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.